Tag Archives: future of marketing

The Four Tenets of A Digital Mindset

The Digital New Fronts showed another maturing stage in the development of online content. It demonstrated the continued blurring of the offline and online worlds. Television series and web series are increasingly utilizing the same talent, pursuing the same audience, and selling to the same advertisers. This blurring will continue as advances in addressable television, tablets, and over-the-top video make the distinction between digital and broadcast content disappear.

This represents both a victory and a conundrum for proponents of digital marketing. The victory rests in the growing importance of social, mobile, and online marketing in the plans of even the most traditional marketers. Several global brands are being built almost entirely on digital marketing strategies.  So, as far as rising to the ranks of market importance, digital has “won.”  But the conundrum is rooted in this same success for digital practitioners of every stripe.  When everything and everyone is using digital, is there any meaningful distinction left in being a digital marketer?

Digital marketers used to distinguish themselves based on their mastery of channels that most other people didn’t understand. They knew how to design websites, build rich media banners, and bid on search terms. That knowledge is both more widespread and easier to tap into than ever before.  That said, there is still something quite valuable about true digital marketing. It’s not about the toolset; it’s about the mindset. What is still lacking for many marketers and agencies is the mindset that comes from a digital way of looking at that world.  There are four core tenets underlying the digital mindset:

Everything is Connected

The digital imperative is to constantly seek new points of connection. In marketing, digital brands find new ways to connect across multiple levels.  Those connections can be made across time, people, information, and interests.  In that way, it can connect brand building with sales, existing customers with potential customers, R&D with Customer Service, etc. Where traditional marketing tends to separate into channels, digital marketing is always finding new ways to link together.

Actions Trump Impressions

Traditional marketers often measure the effectiveness of their efforts by the impressions they generate. Even experiential efforts like live events are reported in terms of how many equivalent impressions they generated. The digital mindset sees value in actions. An action is a measure of commitment, while an impression is only a measure of exposure.  If you’re looking to make a friend, interacting with someone will get far better results than being seen by someone. Similarly, if you can get someone to post something, share something, or like something then you are far more likely to sell something, either to that person or someone they know.  In that view, getting a thousand people to do something is more valuable than getting a million people to see something.

Always Optimizing

The traditional marketing cycle is like a movie release. The marketers spend months developing a new story, work behind the scenes to perfect the details, and after several months, launch it to the world in a glorious finale. If it succeeds, you make a sequel; it if fails you start over with a new one. The digital mindset embraces the beta view of software development. The launch is seen as more a beginning than an end. By gathering feedback and measuring reactions, the first release gets tweaked and upgraded.  In the digital view, a release does not have the rigidity of a final cut, but the malleability of software code.

Data is Currency

All of these elements are driven by data. To be digital, you need to be know how to harvest, process, and analyze data.  And it’s not just for performance metrics. Performance measurement is vital, but data provides much more than that. Digital marketers are excited by data because it reveals new connections, shows what people are really doing, and points the way to building deeper relationships. The digital mindset not only recognizes the awesome business potential of data, but the amazing creative potential of data as well.

Having the latest digital tools doesn’t make you a digital marketer anymore than owning a chessboard makes you a chess player.  For both qualifications, the proof is in how you play the game.

Leave a comment

Filed under 21st Century Marketing, Digital Marketing, Innovation

The Growing Reality of Always On Marketing

It’s said that the future lies clearly in the present, as long as you know where to look. If you look at the underpinnings of today’s rising brands, a pattern emerges. There is, of course, the by-now standard dictum of a shared brand experience.  The idea of talking with people instead of at them is no less true for now being common wisdom. What’s less common are brands who have taken it to the next step.  It is one thing to have a Twitter manager lobbing out pseudo-conversational tidbits such as “what’s your favorite Super Bowl snack?” It is another thing entirely to know to whom you’re talking to and being able to share something with them of real interest based on the context of that particular moment. This is at the heart of Always On marketing.  Like most marketing innovations, Always On marketing started with small niche brands finding new ways to build buzz outside traditional approaches. Now you see established brands like AMEX, JetBlue and Gatorade adopting Always On principles.

What is Always On?

At its heart, it’s a simple premise. Always On marketing is the ability to respond in real-time to an individual customer with the most relevant brand content.  If I’m in the market for a new smartphone, and I don’t know whether I want an iPhone or Android model, a carrier who serves up reviews of the two types of phone would have an advantage winning me over as a customer. If I’m away from home at my kid’s basketball tournament, and a quick-service restaurant sends me a coupon and directions to their place around the corner, they’re likely to get a sale.  While a simple idea in theory, in practice it requires a new set of capabilities.

What’s Driving It?

The drive for Always On marketing side is a combination of developments on both the producer and consumer side of the equation. In total, there are three overall developments driving the moves to Always On marketing.

1. The Death of the Funnel

The traditional sales funnel looked something like this:

If this funnel were ever really true, it is not true now. Studies from Y&R, McKinsey Consulting and others show that the brand selection process does not involve a broad embrace of brands at the start, followed by a rational and linear winnowing down to a preferred brand. The McKinsey model suggests a path that looks more like this:

There are several significant differences between this model and the traditional funnel. Most notable are:

  • When something triggers our desire to make a purchase, we start with a narrow preconceived set of brands, not a wide view of the category
  • That initial set of brands may actually grow instead of narrow as we evaluate our choices.
  • The move from the initial trigger to the final purchase may skip a step at any point.

This revised view has important implications. For one, it emphasizes how critical it is to understand your brand’s place with a potential customer at each stage of the process. Contrary to traditional funnel thinking, a new challenger brand may have a better chance getting attention in the Active Evaluation stage than the Initial Consideration stage. For another, it encourages forging multiple paths to purchase. Each person goes through their own purchase journey, skipping over one stage to the next.  If that person is forced to confined to a predetermined path, you risk losing their interest and their business. Taken together, it requires a system that can spot when a personal trigger event happens  (e.g., visit to a car dealer, browsing an online catalog, moving to a new town) and act on it immediately. Consider that the average time from a trigger event to a purchase decision is 10-12  days for someone going on a vacation.  The time from trigger to purchase for a mobile phone is about 7 days. Always On marketers who can spot the trigger and market accordingly in that short span of time gain a huge advantage.

2. Great Expectations

Consumer expectations have changed significantly. If you can think back as long as five years ago, the idea that you would shout out a company’s name on the street and expect a personal reply would be grounds for psychiatric evaluation. But Twitter has created an expectation fairly close to that. People register complaints with no more than a company hashtag and are miffed if there is not a response.

This represents a ratcheting up in consumer expectations. People increasingly expect real-time interactions from the brands they care about.

3. Big Data

The burgeoning availability of actionable real-time data provides new opportunities to truly deliver on one-to-one marketing. The “one-to-one marketing “ label has been around for decades, but it was a way of thinking rather than an actual way of working. Traditional database marketing relies on segmentation schema that group people by common characteristics.  Segmentation is a way to break a mass group up into smaller groups, but is not truly individualized.  It creates proxies for real knowledge of the person.  For example, a battery manufacturer would create a “gadget lovers” segment based on demographic and survey data, and design marketing programs targeted in various degrees of specificity to that group. That approach is several times more effective that simple mass marketing. Yet their effectiveness would be even several factors higher than that if they knew nothing about a person’s demographic and survey responses, but did know how many times an individual had purchased batteries in the past six months, what devices they owned, the last time they bought a batteries, and where they were shopping for electronics right now.  In that way, Big Data renders group segmentation obsolete. Always On marketing operates on a segment-of one-philosophy.

What Does Always it Require?

An Always On marketing platform require four major components.

1. A Powerful Marketing Engine

The most critical component of Always On marketing is the ability to gather, process, and act on large amounts of data. Big Data generates a continuous fire hose of data that cannot be meaningfully processed by traditional analytic methods. A Marketing Engine is a collection of tools, partners, and processes that enable a brand to:

  • Combine multiple data sources to construct an actionable profile of each individual they encounter.
  • Apply business rules that allow real-time matches between individuals and brand content
  • Track responses of individuals to brand contacts and pursue different paths with that individual based on the nature of that response
  • Monitor performance across channels in a way that allows for constant optimization

2. Deep Reservoir of Brand Content

Even with the most powerful Marketing Engine in place, it is not effective if the interactions with people aren’t compelling and relevant. That’s why brands need to build and update sources of content that can be at the ready. That content can be constructed dynamically (e.g. customized offers),  pre-produced (e.g. how-to videos), or human (e.g. a customer service representative).  As brands embrace an Always On approach, the content needs will become apparent as their interactions grow and patterns emerge.

3. A Clear Brand Story

One thing that hasn’t changed about effective marketing is the importance of having a compelling brand story.  This is what establishes the fundamental human attraction to brands. In fact, it is even more critical in an Always On environment. That’s because the brand story has to be told in so many more ways that it used to be. As a result, more people are involved in telling the brand story than ever before. Community managers, customer service agents, other employees and brand fans join brand managers as promoters of the brand. They need a clear story that can guide their efforts in concert without centralized control.  While it may seem put of place in a discussion about Marketing Engines and Big Data, the core truth is that storytelling is more essential than ever. Now,  it not only has to inspire the people who hear it, but also inspire the people who tell it.

4. A Different Mindset

All of the above components are critical to deliver Always On marketing. Yet, they won’t work without an accompanying shift in mindset. Many marketing organizations are built to deliver tightly structured campaigns that require extensive time for deliberation, review and testing behind the scenes before each launch. Always On requires a “constant beta” approach where the testing and enhancements are being made in market.  While it is no less rigorous strategically, it embraces a quicker and less predictable cadence. More effort has to be into crafting playbooks and operating principles, and less into approvals of individual executions. In this way, marketing organizations may come to look more like the best customer service organizations, both highly disciplined and highly flexible.

Leave a comment

Filed under 21st Century Marketing, Activation, Innovation

Digital Marketing is Dead – Long Live Digital Marketing

The marketing services community is undergoing yet another spin as the world’s cultural and functional landscape grows ever more digital.  On one side, so-called traditional agencies continue striving to prove that they get digital with all the subtlety of an American Idol audition. On the other side, digital agencies are equally eager to show they can take center stage after years of playing support roles. Both sides fear irrelevance as the “digital” label becomes as redundant to marketing as the word “hard” is to “rock.” When almost every communication medium is technically being created or transmitted digitally, what does it mean to be digital?

You can see the challenge of this realization in how larger agencies are repositioning themselves and their digital arms. Large legacy agencies that excitedly established separate digital arms 8-10 years ago, like Tribal DDB or G2, are now figuring out how to reel them back in. What was seen as innovative then is now seen as damning evidence that your mother company doesn’t understand the digital space. Digital agencies are dealing with different ramifications of the same issue. If all marketing is becoming digital, and some agencies like Weiden and Goodby show themselves to be as creative in the digital arena as they were in  broadcast, are digital agencies starting to look too specialized to drive big brand ideas?

For marketers trying to sort this all out, it’s best to avoid the labels of traditional and digital. They may have been helpful for understanding what these places did in the past, but they are not helpful for what they can do for a brand now. The world may be going digital, but that does not mean that digital agencies are the best choice for marketers going forward. Too many digital agencies got that title because of their expertise with a particular toolset – websites, mobile apps or social community management. The current rise of digital goes beyond the toolset. It is the influence on our culture and expectations where digital is now having the most impact. People who’ve never redeemed a GroupOn or tweeted a word are thinking and behaving differently because of the impact the digital world is having on everything we do. In that sense, being digital is no longer about a toolset, it is about a mindset.

Marketers looking for a partner who can help then succeed in the modern marketplace want an agency with a digital mindset regardless of their historical toolset. In a marketing sense, a digital mindset means:

Invitations vs. Performances

When you think of your potential customers in terms of an audience, you think in terms of performing for them. It’s your show, and they are there to enjoy it.  You’re looking for feedback, but only of a limited kind — applause, cheers, laughter, boos.  If you think of  your customers as participants in your brand, you think in terms of inviting them to join with what you’re doing. Sometimes you’ll both be in the audience together, sharing common interests. Sometimes you’ll both be on stage, sharing new product ideas. In these and every situation in between, an invitation-mentality reflects the digital sensibility of marketing with people instead of to them.

2.1 vs. Ta Da

A traditional mindset sees success as an event, whereas a digital mindset sees it more as a process. The traditional campaign mentality treats each new effort as one-time attempt to get it right. You work on pulling work together for six months or so, then unveil it to the world like a movie or a book launch. The digital mentality sees a world that is more iterative. In the digital experience, you don’t expect to get everything right in your first version. You build it as best you can, and you expect to have to issue new versions to address issues or opportunities you did not foresee, or that may not have been there when you started.  No success is expected to continue without continual refinement and improvement. A traditional mindset tends to see the world in discrete episodes. A digital mindset sees the world more as real-time stream.

Speed Skating vs Figure Skating

Figure skating and speed skating both involve competitions on ice, but success takes different paths. In figure skating, you are the best in the world to the extent that you can convince an influential panel of judges that you are the best. In many ways, it is equivalent to how agencies used to get ranked. If you won a lot of awards from judges who thought you were good, that meant you were good. In speed skating, you are the best if you go faster than anybody else. Digital agencies love measuring. They’re hungry to prove what’s working. They don’t only use data at the end to build the case study, they use it in the beginning to shape the work. Marketing will always constitute some measure of both art and science, but digital agencies look for inspiration from them both.

Architects vs. Authors

If  I ask  who wrote “The Great Gatsby,” many could tell me it was F. Scott Fitzgerald. If I ask  who built the Empire State Building, the answer is both less well-known and less clear. An author takes satisfaction in literally crafting every word of their work. Owning the idea in the literary world means owning both the overarching concept and each detail of its execution. You rarely see books credited to more than one author. The traditional mindset has a similar instinct around enshrining the auteur. Architects, on the other hand,  know that their craft requires collaboration across many fields. They put forward the vision, but recognize the critical need for fellow engineers, builders, interior designers, and a host of others to make the idea come to life. The architect parallels the digital mindset that naturally looks to partnership as the operative model.

Digital marketing is entering a new phase where is less about mastering the technology and more about mastering the cultural dynamic. The tools will constantly be changing, so the toolset becomes less relevant. The digital mindset is what will drive marketing into the next phase.

Leave a comment

Filed under 21st Century Marketing, Innovation, Uncategorized